“Lady In The Water” stars overlooked actor Paul Giamatti (Sideways), and Bruce Dallas Howard, known for her breakthrough performance in “The Village”. Written, directed, and produced by M. Night Shyamalan, this is his most insufficient film yet.
An apartment superintendant find a woman named Story swimming in his outdoor pool. This mysterious woman claims to be a “Narf” in need of help. Being chased by a creature called a “Scrunt”. This underwater lady must find her way back to the Blue World and the only way to do this is by flight of an eagle that is suppose to come and rescue her. With the help of the stuttering superintendent, she hope to make it back to her water-dwelling world.
When the opening scene is the best scene in a movie, you know something went drastically wrong. I was very engaged from the opening scene with the hieroglyphics. The movie was slowly paced and the directing was top-notch sleaziness. All of M. Night Shamalyan’s films have been going downhill, but this one hits rock bottom, giving me confidence to say that everything from here is uphill. A very tame and spiritless film from a very subtle filmmaker. An embarrassing attempt at making a worth while movie experience.
Having such a disappointing and discouraging ending, once again felt riped-off by renting this bedtime movie. It will put you to sleep if you have a bad case of insomnia. Don’t expect to be shocked, amazed, or even in this case entertained by any moment in the movie. The trailer made it seem like a horror movie, when in fact it is more like a poorly written children’s story. This gives me confidence that his next film can’t be any worse than this one. A fluke and a total mess of a movie.
With a hefty amount of razzie nominations under it’s belt, I would have to say this was worst than any other movie made that year. A completely absurd film. The underdeveloped screenplay and horrendously bad acting proves that M. Night Shyamalan had no idea as to what he was doing. Bad dialog and careless acting as if they were forced to play the roles. What a sinker this movie turned out to be. M. Night Shyamalan’s first true misfire and simply the worst film of 2006.
The above author's byline must be attached to the work if being distributed.






February 3rd, 2008 at 10:56 pm
I agree, this movie was very bad, but I disagree that this was M. Night Shyamalan’s first stinker. I thought that the one in the woods (name I can’t currently remember) was horrible. And Signs wasn’t a wonder either. Since The Sixth Sense he has had a hard time getting back to the acclaim he had there. Although I must admit, Lady in the Water has been the worst. I wish I didn’t wait the time to see it, and had seen something more rewarding instead.
February 3rd, 2008 at 10:59 pm
I enjoyed the concept behind “The Villiage”. I admit I didn’t like “The Villiage” the first time I saw it, but it dawned on me that the concept was pretty good.
February 3rd, 2008 at 11:00 pm
Yeah, the villiage, that’s what it was. To me the concept was old news, it plays out in a lot of sci-fi books and in some horror.
February 4th, 2008 at 1:27 am
I’m always amazed at how many people didn’t like Lady in the Water. Or Signs for that matter, which is one of my favorite Shyamalan films.
I would love to review Lady in the Water at some point, but have never been able to collate my thoughts enough to do so.
June 29th, 2008 at 2:24 am
lol @ the comments made by the critic. I agree. this movie is poorly written and extremely boring. When I saw the movie on HBO, I was so happy that I did not spend my money to watch this film in the theaters. This film needed more work.