Director - George A. Romero
Writer - Goerge A. Romero
Starring - Michelle Morgan, Josua Close, Shawn Roberts, Amy Ciupak Lalonde, Philip Roccio
Review:
As inventive and original as the premise for this newest slice of cinematic zombie life might have seemed a few years ago, it has arrived onto our screens a little too late. As a result George A. Romero’s Diary of the Dead, with the exception of a few decent scares and an admirable humanistic message behind it, doesn’t really work the way I imagine it was supposed to.
While filming their own low-budget horror film in the woods, a group of students get word of a very large dose of terror sweeping the country in the form of the dead coming back to life and attacking the living. The group immediately try to make their way home but obviously not all goes to plan.
Almost 40 years and three more instalments in the Dead series since Night of the Living Dead, legendary filmmaker George A. Romero adds a fifth instalment to the much loved horror franchise. This time around the concept of the dead returning back to life has been given a twist; it’s done from the perspective of a group of student’s video cameras and the aim is to show everything exactly from that perspective only. The trouble is the film doesn’t always stick to this idea completely and as a result this undermines its premise and the film as a whole. Admittedly the film is most effective when attacks of the zombies are shown handicam style, reflecting the frantic nature of what it would actually be like for that situation to arise in real life. But it’s the lack of commitment to the premise and the question of, “why would they still be filming this and not running for their lives?” that keeps the film from staying truly believable and effective throughout.
As I have said the concept of showing events within a film from a video camera was an interesting one when it was created ten years ago with The Blair Witch Project and even when it was revitalized not long ago with the highly enjoyable Cloverfield. Diary of the Dead’s late arrival means the concept is outdated and thus it’s emphasise on that concept being special comes off as nothing of the sort and instead left me, for one, annoyed by an hour in and just wishing I could watch everything in the regular way. That’s not to say that they don’t have some neat tricks up their sleeves. There are a few moments of genuinely effective scares, most notably the opening few minutes where victims of a shootout come back to life on a hospital gurney and bite the aiding paramedics, but the problem is there just isn’t enough of them. So completely scary the film is not, and it doesn’t help that there is a number of, let’s just say, questionable performances from the cast to catch the eye of anyone paying closer attention than just wanting some jump scares.
The characters we see throughout the film are pretty much all annoyingly clichéd. From the sure-to-be-victim blonde hottie to the drunken know-it-all professor, the main protagonists of the film aren’t exactly original but this is nicely counterbalanced, something probably not on purpose, by a host of strange minor characters that inspire a few laughs from the audience. Most notably a deaf, amish and conveniently helpful old man and a group of black, gang-like men with heavy artillery and much needed supplies. It was strange to me that there would be such clichéd characters on the forefront and yet such original and interesting characters taking the back, like I said probably an accident on Romero’s part.
So although there are problems-a-plenty in Diary of the Dead, the biggest of which is that the concept is now thoroughly outdated, the film fan in me was pleased to see the classic, slow-moving zombies return to the big-screen. This may be a work of a director far past his filmmaking prime but for fans of him and this style of movie, this latest serving of zombie pie should hold something to enjoy. But for the rest of you I would probably give this one a miss.
















